Prostitution remains a crime in South Australia but sexual services go on in other guises

South Australian prostitution stays criminal but remains tolerated in the background.

During parliamentary debate in 1885, Dr John Cockburn (SA premier 1889-90 and women’s suffrage supporter) warned that it was “absolutely impossible to abolish brothels.”

This seemed to be confirmed in 1907 when police reported 103 brothels and 164 people involved in operating them in Adelaide.

Yet in the same year, the state government presented the Suppression of Brothels Bill, largely in response to concerns voiced by the Adelaide City Council that properties next to brothels “deteriorated in value”.

In 1920, penalties were introduced for allowing a person with venereal disease to be in a house or place for the purpose of prostitution.
The Police Act 1936 consolidated prostitution as a criminal offence and the 1953 Police Offences Bill contained the basis of the prostitution laws that still apply in the state.

While today’s South Australian prostitution legislation is based on acts from the 1930s and 1950s, at least six attempts have been made to reform the laws, starting in 1980.

When a parliamentary select committee of inquiry recommended decriminalisation. Robin Millhouse, a former Liberal attorney-general, but at that time a Liberal Movement member, moved that the committee’s recommendation be adopted. After considerable community opposition, the move failed on a tied vote in the House of Assembly.

Meanwhile, sexual services continued to be offered opened under the guise of massage parlour or escourts.

Other related ADELAIDEAZ articles

19th Century concept of women as property feeds into ongoing domestic violence

South Australia remains part of the growing awareness of domestic violence and its increasing rates of death across Australia in the 21st Century. This is an overhang from the 19th Century when the status of women as property was as dominant as the right to vote in the women’s rights struggle. Besides having no claim to property, married women had few rights if deserted by husbands or caught in violent relationships. It was lawful for husbands to beat their wives.

Sexual moral outrage of Social Purity Society in 19th Century flows to 1970s Festival of Light

The prostitution rife in Adelaide city streets since the colony’s start prompted outrage and groups such as the Social Purity Society. On the same theme, the Festival of Light, a Christian lobby group formed in the 1970s to promote certain standards and strengthen the family unit, had its first Australian branch founded in Adelaide in 1973 by Helen Caterer and the Rev. Lance Shilton. Mary Whitehouse came to Adelaide to launch it at a gathering of 12,000 on Montefiore Hill.


Pianist Maude Puddy brings London/Vienna teaching/performance back to Conservatorium

Maude Puddy was among the most remarkable early Elder Conservatorium graduates. Puddy was gifted from an early age. Her father, a fitter and turner and self-taught pianist, encouraged her playing. She attended Hindmarsh Public School and, at age 10, won joint first prize with a 15-year-old at the Public Schools Floral and Industrial Exhibition. In 1900, at 17, she gained Adelaide University's first associate of music diploma. In 1905, Puddy left for a year in London, then to Vienna as pupil of eminent piano teacher Theodor Leschetizky. From 1919, she returned to the Conservatorium as a teacher for three decades. She inspired eminent visitors to the Conservatorium including fellow Leschetizky pupils Ignaz Friedman, Benno Moiseiwitsch and Ignacy Jan Paderewski, along with renowned Australians Lauri Kennedy, Nellie Melba and Percy Grainger. Puddy continued giving world-class solo concerts. She played with the South Australian and Verbrugghen orchestras, and she was among the first classical musicians to embrace wireless broadcasting, performing on 5CL from the 1920s.


Lillie Smith's Girton Girls (1915) and King's College (1920s) joined to form Pembroke School

Pembroke School – an upmarket independent coeducation and nondenominational day and boarding school in Adelaide’s Kensington Park for about 1700 students – was formed in 1974 by amalgamating Girton Girls School and King’s School for boys. Girton was one of many private girls’ schools started in Adelaide. Lillie Smith, wife of a stock broker whose fortunes varied, decided to have a regular income by buying a Kensington property in 1915 and setting up her school for girls. It flourished for nearly 50 years. King’s College came out of 1920s moves to amalgamate the Congregational, Methodist and Presbyterian churches. Although union didn’t happen, a new cooperative spirit led to the Baptists joining Congregationalists to form King’s College. King’s College emphasised the academic, physical and cultural rather than faith. Its only clergyman headmaster R.A. Cook (from 1957) eventually had a school chapel built in the 1960s. First headmaster J.A. Haslam, was the son of a Methodist minister, and later W.N. Oats, a Quaker with strong Methodist background, revived the school, from 1942. Among challenging views, Oats’ vision for King’s to become co-educational wasn't realised for another 30 years. In 2006, Pembroke became the first South Australian school exempted o accept more girls than boys to redress a gender imbalance in lower years. Pembroke School Foundation has supported major additions such as Diana Medlin Junior School, John Moody Technology Centre, senior and middle schools’ resource centres and Girton arts precinct.

Among many causes, Catherine Helen Spence heads clothing company with good conditions

Another leading South Australian women's suffrage campaigner, Catherine Helen Spence was active in many causes. She chaired the all-female South Australian Co-operative Clothing Co., Adelaide's first electric-powered clothing factory, set up in 1902, to protect women workers from being exploited in the “sweating” system. She was a prime mover, with Caroline Emily Clark, of the Boarding-out Society, aimed at removing destitute children from the asylum into approved families.

Suffrage cause grows from an alliance for temperance, working conditions, social purity

The main groups campaigning to get the vote for South Australian women were the Women’s Suffrage League, the Women’s Christian Temperance Union and Working Women’s Trade Union. This alliance was concerned about the effects of alcohol, sexual purity and working conditions on family stability. To make change, they needed the vote. The Women's Suffrage League, set up in 1888, organised petitions, lobbied MPs and mustered many women to attend the debates.

Contact Us

We welcome positive constructive feedback