South Australian state borders caught in the middle of historical quirks back to 1494

Maps showing the history of South Australia's boundary anomalies.
Maps courtesy Dr Gerard Carney

South Australia’s state borders, abutting every other mainland state, are an historical oddity that retain their quirks.

The South Australian Colonisation Act 1834 defined the boundaries on the west at 132 degrees longitude and on the east at 141 degrees longitude. The official reason for choosing the 132 degrees western boundary is obscure but it may be linked to it running through Eyre Peninsula’s Fowler’s Bay, mentioned by Matthew Flinders as bring the first protected bay after the inaccessible Great Australian Bight cliffs.

But the 132 degree western border left South Australia surrounded by New South Wales as it was in 1836. The New South Wales western border, at 129 degrees, was shared with the new Western Australia from 1831. This left a No Man’s Land on South Australia’s west between its border and the WA/NSW border. This anomaly was only eliminated in 1861.

(The reason for the original New South Wales border being at the 129 degrees is rooted in history going back to the 1494 Treaty of Toedesillas, dividing control over the New World between Spain and Portugal.)

The unmarked eastern border between New South Wales and South Australia became a pressing concern. Eventually, after exploring alternative border possibilities, the two colonies agreed to have their surveyors, Wade and White, mark out a Glenelg River section of boundary line that was officially proclaimed by 1849.

A Wade-White Line was continued to the River Murray in 1850 and it became the South Australia border with Victoria that came into that year. But more accurate technology in 1868 revealed that the Wade-White Line was two miles and 19 chains west of the 141 meridian. South Australia tried unsuccessful appeals all the way to the Privy Council in Britain to have the boundary moved eastward and the issue remains unresolved with the border between the two states running down the middle of River Murray for 11km.

South Australia’s other major border change was its takeover of the Northern Territory from New South Wales in 1863. It later regretted the move and willingly surrendered the territory to the federal government in 1907.

* Information from "The Story behind the Land Borders of the Australian States - A Legal and Historical Overview" by Dr Gerard Carney, Public Lecture Series, High Court of Australia,  2013

Other related ADELAIDEAZ articles

Josiah Symon a giant of late 19th Century law for 30 years on the state and federal stage

Josiah Symon towered over his contemporaries and was acknowledged leader of the South Australian Bar for more than 30 years from 1871. At 29, Symon took charge of one of Adelaide's finest legal practices. He declined being elevated to the supreme court bench in 1884 but was a minister in two South Australian governments. His major contribution as a senator in Australian politics related to federation and especially in his interest and criticism of the early high court of Australia.


Myth fuels dispute over Benjamin Mendes da Costa's gift to Anglican church and St Peter's

An enduring Adelaide myth is that the Anglican Church deprived the Roman Catholic Church of the large bequest from businessman and philanthropist Benjamin Mendes da Costa. The myth is rooted in da Costa’s Portuguese name, suggesting he was Catholic. But da Costa had Jewish lineage and, with sister Louisa, was bought up in the Church of England as a child of his father’s second marriage. (The first-marriage children were brought up Jewish.) Benjamin and sister Louisa (both never married) arrived in South Australia on 1840. He set up as a merchant in Hindley Street and moved to Grenfell Street. He built up property across South Australia but significantly in eight places on Hindley, Rundle, Grenfell, Currie, Gilbert and Pulteney streets plus Hindmarsh Square and South Terrace. The da Costas only stayed in South Australia seven years but when Benjamin died in 1869 he left land for the site of St Peter’s Cathedral and his £20,000 Adelaide property estate to the Collegiate School of St Peter. The dispute over wording of his will concerns which bishop of Adelaide was beneficiary: the Anglican Augustus Short, whom da Costa knew, or the Catholic bishop. A legal case won by the Anglicans on this point is a myth. St Peter’s College didn’t get its bequest until the last of da Costa’s relatives (also heirs) died in 1910.

Eccentric genius Percy
 Grainger inseparable 
from his most devoted mother: 
Adelaide’s Rose

The bizarre and brilliant career of “mad genius” Percy Grainger is inseparable from his Adelaide-born and raised mother Rose (nee Aldridge). Percy and his mother are buried together at Adelaide West Terrace cemetery. Percy’s architect father John migrated to Adelaide in 1877 to join the engineer in chief’s office. He married Rose (Rosa) Aldridge, daughter of a prominent Adelaide hotelier and race horse owner, in 1880. The couple moved to Melbourne where John produced designs for the Princes Bridge and, via her builder father David Mitchell, Nellie Melba’s Coombe Cottage. But, in 1890, John Grainger left for England and never returned. He possibly had passed on the disease syphilis to Rose. This left Rose to foster Percy’s precocious musical talents. Rose was Percy’s constant companion around the world with his reputation soaring, including as a prime exponent of friend Edvard Grieg’s music. Grainger’s personal eccentricities stretched from extremes of his bisexuality to an enormous appetite for sado masochism. Rose’s suicide (by jumping from the Aeolian Building in 42nd Street, New York) in 1922, from despair at false rumours of incest with Percy and the gathering effects of her illness, was a crushing blow for Grainger.

Essington Lewis rises from BHP to Australia's arms industry supremo during World War II

Essington Lewis became one of Australia’s most powerful men during World War II when he dictated and directed Australia’s munitions industry. Born at Burra Burra in 1881, Lewis followed his bushman father in self reliance and hard work. Educated at St Peter’s College and a sports champion (he played football for Norwood and South Australia), Lewis left working on his father’s cattle station to become a mining engineer, enrolling at the South Australian School of Mines and Industries in 1901. In 1904, he joined Broken Hill Proprietary where his work at Port Pirie smelters and projects such as Iron Knob ironstone. He impressed BHP general manager Guilluame Delprat. In 1921, Lewis replaced Gelprat. Lewis took over when the Australian steel industry was floundering, to the extent that BHP’s Newcastle plant had to shut down in 1922. Gaining power as the first executive on the BHP board, Lewis transformed the company’s production techniques, made a shift to rigorous training of Australian (not overseas) engineering executives, and developed steel-using subsidiary companies. Keeping a close watch on overseas trends, Lewis put a resurgent BHP on a war footing, including setting up the Whyalla shipyards, after he saw what was happening in Japan during the 1930s. When World War II started, Lewis was given enormous unquestioned power by the federal government as director of munitions. He controlled production and choice of weapons and equipment. Much of Australia's industrial expansion after the war was based on Lewis’s techniques. Lewis influenced important post-war projects.


Japanese yuzu and green ants among novelties brought to South Australian gin

Gin makers in South Australia are applying the state’s traditional trait of bringing novelty – from the Japanese-native fruit yuzu to Australian green ants – to the drink. The yuzu was grafted onto the fruut trees of the Arnold family near Waikerie and used in gin at McLaren Vale by winemaker Rowland Hill, in a move started by fruit and vegetable wholesaler Margy Abbot. Sacha La Forgia, whose 78 Degrees gin took out a top internationaprize, has used green ants as an ingredient for his gins.

South Australia loses
 two judges – John 
Jeffcott and William 
Wearing – to the sea

South Australia lost two judges to drownings in separate 19th Century incidents. On November 19, 1837, heading for Hobart Town, the colony’s first judge John Jeffcott was waiting in a whaleboat to board his ship at Encounter Bay when the whaleboat capsized, and he drowned at the River Murray. mouth. Jeffcott’s term in South Australia only lasted months. Dismayed at the “dreadful dissensions” in the colony between governor John Hindmarsh (supported by Jeffcott) and his opponents, he was soon looking for a position elsewhere. He was going to Hobart Town to consult with the judges there on South Australian legal difficulties when he drowned. Supreme court judge William Wearing was drowned in 1875 when the Gothenberg was shipwrecked on the Great Barrier Reef. Wearing was returning from the Northern Territory – then administered by South Australia – where he conducted circuit court sittings in Palmerston (now Darwin).

Contact Us

We welcome positive constructive feedback