Lifetime support for own-fault accident victims hits lower-end claims, say lawyers

The 2013 changes to South Australian third party insurance allowed motorists to claim lifetime support for serious injuries in accidents that were their own fault.
Image courtesy ABC News

Law Society of South Australia and injury-claim lawyers have continued to complain about what they say is unfairness in changes to laws relating to accident insurance claims in 2013.

The significant changes in 2013 were the Motor Vehicle Accidents (Lifetime Support Scheme) Act and amendments to the Civil Liability Act 1936. The lifetime support scheme introduced treatment, care and support of those catastrophically injured in motor vehicle accidents that were their own fault. This represented 40% of victims who were previously unable to claim under compulsory third party insurance for treatment and care for lifelong disabilities.

As a result of introducing the costly new Lifetime Support Authority, the state government brought in changes to the lower end of the scheme affecting those with more minor injuries from a vehicle accident. At this lower end, drivers had to score more than 11 out of 100 points on an injury-severity scale to get compensation over and above loss of income and medical bills or “pain and suffering” payments.

The government said it made the changes to make car insurance more affordable and that the scheme had saved the average motorist $140 in car registration fees. Lawyers argued that those savings had all but disappeared and, in the meantime, car crash victims who have suffered broken limbs, a loss of vision, or even some brain damage, were being refused pain-and-suffering compensation because they scored less than 8/100 under the changes to the compulsory third-party insurance scheme.

Lawyers also suggested the 2013 changes anticipated the sale of South Australia’s compulsory third party insurance system to private companies.

Other related ADELAIDEAZ articles

End of South Australian Railways country trains with federal takeover; a win for road transport

After American commissioner William Webb left in 1930, the old hierarchy returned to the South Australian Railways and dismantled his reforms. But railways were struggling against other forces that were eroding their freight and passenger numbers. In the 1930s, the state government had stemmed one threat to railways through the Road and Railways Transport Act that imposed costs on road transport freight carriers. That act was repealed in 1963. Meanwhile, rising car ownership was cutting the number of passengers using trains. South Australian Railways commissioner Ron Fitch warned of the mounting financial losses. To arrest declining passenger numbers in the 1950s-60s, airconditioned Bluebird rail cars were introduced on country services in 1954 and, next year, Red Hen rail cars began operating on Adelaide suburban lines. The last steam engines ran in South Australia in 1970, ending a history that began in 1856 at the Port Dock station at Port Adelaide. In 1975, South Australian Railways was sold to a federal government agency and all its country passenger services ended. In 1978, Commonwealth Railways, South Australian Railways and the Tasmanian Government Railways merged to form Australian National railways. Australian National took over operating all federal and non-urban South Australian railway lines. The State Transport Authority of South Australia (later TransAdelaide) was created to run all Adelaide suburban rail lines for the state government.

John Jeffcott only lasts a few months: first to two South Australian judges to be drowned in the sea

The first criminal sessions of the South Australian courts were under the colony’s first judge, Justice John Jeffcott, on May 13, 1837. Jeffcott’s term was short. He drowned at the River Murray mouth on November 19. (South Australia lost another supreme court judge, William Wearing, to the sea in 1875, when the Gothenberg, bringing him back from the circuit court in Palmerston, later Darwin, was wrecked on the Great Barrier Reef.) Jeffcott was appointed the colony’s first judge in England in 1836 but, settling his affairs (he'd been acquitted of a murder charge in 1834), meant he didn’t arrive in Adelaide until April 1837. Jeffcott “admitted three Englishmen to practise in the roles of barrister, solicitor and proctor” to start the South Australian justice structure. At the first criminal courts sitting, he congratulated the colony for, unlike others, allowing trial by jury. William Light was jury foreman. The court admitted the public prosecutor as a practitioner. Seven prisoners were presented on charges of burglary, break and enter, and rioting. Dismayed at the “dreadful dissensions” between governor John Hindmarsh (supported by Jeffcott) and his opponents, Jeffcott soon was looking for a position elsewhere. He was given leave to go to Hobart Town to consult with judges there on South Australian legal legal difficulties. On November 19, Jeffcott was waiting to board his ship in Encounter Bay when the whaleboat he was in capsized.

Adelaide University law school nation's second from 1883; Flinders Law an innovator from 1992

Adelaide University law school, founded in 1883, was one of the 19th Century pioneers in the English tradition of teaching law as a university discipline. The state’s other law school at Flinders University also has been an innovator since its start in 1992. Adelaide University has Australia’s second oldest law school teaching the LLB degree. It was first to admit women to study law in Australia and continues to lead with world-leading research, including law for military uses of outer space. Its role through the South Australian Law Reform Institute has become critical and it’s a national leader in insolvency, taxation, labour and constitutional law. Its alumni includes all the 20th/21st centuries’ South Australian chief justices as well as political figures such as Julia Gillard, Julie Bishop, Penny Wong, Jay Weatherill and Christopher Pyne. Adelaide law school’s Ligertwood Building, opened in 1967, has one of Australia’s best law libraries and a moot court for the 1400-plus students (more than half women). Flinders University’s law school’s first 60 undergraduates were admitted to its bachelor of laws in 1992. In 1999, bachelor of laws and legal practice offered Flinders students a degree and training in law as a barrister or solicitor. This allowed students to qualify to practise without upfront fees for the final part of their training. Flinders Law now has innovative criminal justice and legal studies majors plus bachelor of justice and society programmes.

Adelaide City E-scooter trial extends to added carbon savings in venture with EcoCaddy

Two electric scooter companies, Singapore-based Beam and Melbourne-based Ride, begin operating a six-month trial across Adelaide CBD in 2019. They were chosen by Adelaide City Council ahead of Californian company Lime that run a four-week pilot program with 500 scooters used for 140,000 trips during the Adelaide Fringe. The shortlisted operators were assessed on criteria, including ability to restrict an e-scooter’s speed and braking. The council said Lime didn’t meet requirements because it wouldn't force its e-scooters to stop if they went outside the council-imposed boundaries. GPS-tracked and operated with a smartphone app, the new e-scooters operating in Adelaide were required by the council to reduce to a speed of four kilometres per hour. The new permit is limited to the CBD. If riders go beyond this (or into Rundle Mall no-go zone), Beam and Ride’s e-scooters will slow to a stop. Ride scooters has become a partner of Adelaide-born micro-mobility company EcoCaddy that operates a CBD pedal-assisted electric bike passenger service. In a deal maximising their common aim of reducing carbon emissions, Ride scooters and EcoCaddy developed a battery swapping system. Instead of a truck picking up scooters each day to move them to in-demand pickup points or to the depot for recharging, the batteries are swapped by a mechanic on an EcoCaddy bike. An EcoCargo trailer was designed to carry scooters around. The partnership worked so well that Ride scooters and EcoCaddy were looking to take it to the national level.

Glenelg line extended in 2007 but trams ADELink halted and privatisation announced in 2019

Glenelg line remained Adelaide’s only tramway from 1958 until 2007 when it was extended from Victoria Square in the city to North Terrace and onto the Adelaide Entertainment Centre at Hindmarsh, in 2009. Sections down to Adelaide Festival Centre/Adelaide Oval from King William Street and from Adelaide Railway Station eastward down North Terrace to the former Royal Adelaide Hospital site were added in 2018. Government proposals back to 2013 envisaged an AdeLINK tram network to include: • CityLINK –  a loop along the Morphett Street, Sturt Street, Halifax Street and Frome Street. • PortLINK – converting Outer Harbor train line to a tram to Outer Harbor, Port Adelaide and Grange, and tram lines to West Lakes and Semaphore • EastLINK − a tram line along The Parade, Norwood, to Magill. • WestLINK –  along Henley Beach Road to Henley Square, with a branch to Adelaide Airport. The line to Glenelg would be part of WestLINK • ProspectLINK − from Grand Junction Road along Prospect Road and O’Connell Street • UnleyLINK –along Unley Road and Belair Road to Mitcham. Six French-made Alstom Citadis model 302 trams  from Madrid in 2017 added to the German Bombadier Flexity Classics that replaced Type H trams on Glenelg line in 2006. The Liberal state government elected in 2018 put AdeLINK plans on hold. It also was unable to fulfil a promised right-hand turn from King William Street, Adelaide, for the tram running down the eastern end of North Terrace, Adelaide. In 2019, the government announced plans to privatise the trams along with Adelaide suburban trains network.

Contact Us

We welcome positive constructive feedback