LGBTIQCrime

Adelaide academic Dr George Duncan's death in 1972 spotlights gay harassment by some members of police force

Adelaide academic Dr George Duncan's death in 1972 spotlights gay harassment by some members of police force
Headline from Adelaide's afternoon newspaper The News on July 5, 1972, reporting on the inquest into Dr George's Duncan's death.

Dr George Duncan, gay and a law lecturer at Adelaide University, and another man, Roger James, were confronted at 11pm on May 10, 1972, by a gang of men on Adelaide’s River Torrens southern bank, near the university footbridge.

Both men were thrown into the water but Duncan couldn’t swim and drowned. James suffered a broken ankle in the attack. He crawled up to Victoria Drive. A passing motorist took him to hospital. He later refused to identify the attackers.

Shortly after police retrieved Duncan's body, a television news crew arrived. Police placed the body back in the river and dragged it out again for the camera.

In 1970s Adelaide, homosexuality was illegal and the southern bank of the River Torrens in the heart of the city was a well-known meeting spot for gay people.

A coroner's inquest began in June, 1972, at which two members of the vice squad refused to answer questions. They and a third detective were suspended and later resigned. The inquest found that Dr Duncan, 41, died from violence inflicted by unknown persons. A subsequent police investigation also failed to identify suspects.

Amid a charged political atmosphere, premier Don Dunstan authorised police to call in New Scotland Yard detectives. The case revealed the previously little-known practice among a few police officers of terrorising gay men by the Torrens.

In 1985, former vice squad member Mick O’Shea told an Adelaide newspaper that there had been a coverup to protect three other squad members who he said killed Duncan. In 1986, the three were charged with his manslaughter. Only two faced trial and both were acquitted in 1988. A police taskforce on the case was disbanded in 1990.

South Australian police continued to offer a $200,000 reward for information leading to a conviction in the case.

Other related ADELAIDE AZ articles

Heather Bartholomew (left), her seven children and two relatives, were killed by her husband Clifford in September 1971 at Hope Forest in South Australia. Inset: Craig Cook exclusively revealed in the Sunday Mail, Adelaide, in 2017, the surprise second life of Clifford Bartholomew after he was released early from Yatala prison.
National >
Clifford Bartholomew's secret sequel to killing 10 family members at South Australia's Hope Forest, September 1971
READ MORE+
South Australian government agency Forensic Science SA became the independent scientific collector of evidence at crime scenes. 
Science >
Forensic Science SA (South Australia) does autopsies, collects crime evidence, provides drug and alcohol testing
READ MORE+
Cassie Sainsbury stayed in the public spotlight after her return to Adelaide in 2022 after her time in a Columbian prison on a cocaine smuggling charge, with a celebrity spot on Australian national television reality show SAS Australia: Buried Alive.
Crime >
Cassie Sainsbury back in Adelaide in 2022, after cocaine smuggling prison term, with celebrity status on TV
READ MORE+
The memorial to the Waterloo Bay incident near Elliston on the Eyre Peninsula.
Crime >
Waterloo Bay tribute to Aboriginals killed on cliffs near Elliston on South Australia's Eyre Peninsula in 1849
READ MORE+
South Australian police members in uniform, taking part in Adelaide’s annual gay pride march in 2015.
LGBTIQ >
Members of the South Australian police force allowed to be in uniform for Adelaide's gay pride march from 2105
READ MORE+
Headline from Adelaide's afternoon newspaper The News on July 5, 1972, reporting on the inquest into Dr George's Duncan's death.
LGBTIQ >
Adelaide academic Dr George Duncan's death in 1972 spotlights gay harassment by some members of police force
READ MORE+